The Real Nursing Workforce Crisis: Violence, Toxic Leadership and a Failure to Listen

Unsafe workplaces, workplace violence and toxic leadership are driving nurses away from healthcare. Jeff Doucette, a nationally recognized nursing executive, says hospitals need to look beyond recruitment and start addressing why nurses don’t want to stay.
The nursing shortage has become one of healthcare’s most familiar talking points. Hospitals struggle to fill positions, nursing schools face pressure to educate more graduates, and healthcare organizations keep investing in recruitment to keep their units staffed.
But what if the problem isn’t simply that there aren’t enough nurses? What if healthcare is losing nurses who are already educated, experienced and willing to work, but no longer willing to work under the conditions being asked of them?
That’s the argument Jeff Doucette, DNP, RN, has been making.
“We have about 80,000 nurses a year who leave the work environment because of factors like … workplace violence, toxic leadership, other challenges with feeling like they don’t have the resources that they need to be successful,” Doucette told host Jana Price on Nurse Converse, recorded at the 2026 ANCC Magnet & Pathway Conference in Chicago.
Doucette brings more than three decades of nursing leadership experience to the conversation. He has served as a chief nursing officer, led the Magnet and Pathway to Excellence programs at the American Nurses Credentialing Center (ANCC), and most recently served as chief nursing officer at Press Ganey. He is now chief clinical officer at Qualtrics, which completed its acquisition of Press Ganey in 2026, and was recently named one of Modern Healthcare’s 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives.
His perspective challenges the usual approach to the nursing workforce crisis. He acknowledges that the country faces a real pipeline problem and must keep educating enough nurses, but he believes healthcare leaders are overlooking the nurses already in the profession.
“Is there a shortage? The short answer is yes, but it’s way more complicated than that,” he said.
His argument is that hospitals cannot solve a retention problem by recruiting more nurses. If experienced nurses keep leaving because of unsafe conditions, workplace violence and toxic leadership, the cycle will continue no matter how many new graduates enter the workforce.
“If we could keep those 80,000 nurses in health systems, the pipeline problem would not be as dramatic,” he said.
Want to see more Nurse.org articles in your Google results? Add us as a preferred source.

When nurses talk about workplace violence, the conversation often centers on the immediate incident: the assault, the injury, the threat or the report filed afterward. In Nurse.org’s 2026 workplace violence survey, 27% of nurses said they were physically assaulted at work in 2025, and most didn’t report it. Doucette believes healthcare leaders need to understand the longer-term consequences, particularly whether an employee ever feels comfortable returning to work.
“I think it’s a workforce retention issue now, and any leader who doesn’t believe that is not paying attention,” he said.
He believes organizations that take workplace violence seriously do far more than write a zero-tolerance policy. They invest in prevention and mitigation, have a process that kicks in immediately when a threat or assault happens, and keep supporting employees long after the initial event. That support can include helping nurses press charges and sending legal representation to court if they choose to pursue a case.
“The best organizations truly have a zero-tolerance policy,” he said.
Doucette is particularly critical of organizations that hesitate to hold perpetrators accountable because of concerns about negative publicity.
“Leaders who talk about workplace violence, but then, ‘Well, we don’t want to press charges because that might make the organization look bad or might generate some negative PR,’ those are leaders who really don’t get it.”
Equally troubling to him is the tendency to question clinicians about what they could have done differently after an assault.
“We need to not make this about the clinician,” he said. “Because if I hear one more person say to a nurse or a physician, ‘Tell me what you could have done differently in this situation,’ there’s really nothing that upsets me more than that.”
Doucette also supports federal legislation addressing violence against healthcare workers. He compared it with assaults on airline crews, which are federal crimes, and said violence against healthcare workers deserves the same recognition. Today, those protections vary from state to state.
Healthcare organizations often respond to staffing challenges with sign-on bonuses, retention incentives and higher salaries. Those strategies may help attract nurses, but Doucette said the data suggests compensation is not what makes them stay.
The engagement surveys his company runs measure about 30 reasons nurses give for intending to stay with an organization. Three consistently rise to the top.
“The top reasons that nurses choose to stay in an organization is that they like the work that they do. They like the people they do the work with. And they feel like they are making a difference in the organization.”
Staffing, resources and pay, by comparison, are “almost always jockeying for position at the bottom of that list,” he said. The analysis accounts for whether organizations pay at the median for their market. Pay still matters when an employer falls far below market rates, but when compensation is comparable, the environment and the relationship with leadership matter much more.
“There’s almost no correlation between pay and staffing and long-term intent to stay,” he said. “It’s really about the environment that I’m working in and the leader that I work for.”
He also explained why some organizations may misread their own retention problems.
“It’s so much easier for a nurse to look at a leader and say, ‘I’m going down the road for a dollar an hour,’ than it is to say, ‘I’m leaving because I feel like you’re creating a toxic environment.’”
A nurse may give pay as the reason for leaving when the real issue is harder to discuss: an unsupportive manager, an unhealthy workplace culture or the feeling that leadership doesn’t care. Organizations that focus only on compensation may keep losing nurses even after raising salaries.
Doucette described an analysis last year of about a million employees that examined psychological safety, physical safety and whether nurses felt they could provide safe, effective care.
Psychological safety is about whether employees can speak up when something doesn’t make sense, or when they don’t feel safe, without fear of retaliation. Physical safety covers basics like weapons screening, holding people accountable and giving nurses a button to push if they’re alone at the end of a hall and something goes wrong.
“When employees felt both psychologically safe and physically safe, and then a nurse felt like they could deliver safe, effective, error-free care, employee engagement went from the 50th percentile to the 99th,” he said.
When even one of those conditions was missing, engagement dropped to the first percentile.
“There’s nothing that you can do to service recover with an employee if they’re not feeling safe or don’t feel like they can deliver safe care,” he said.
Recognition programs, wellness initiatives and annual surveys all have a place, but they cannot make up for a workplace where nurses are afraid to speak up, worried about being assaulted or unable to give patients the care they need.
“All of the things that an organization does around employee engagement are critically important, but only work when they are underpinned with safety.”
Healthcare organizations collect a great deal of workforce data. Nurses are surveyed about engagement, asked about safety and given chances to share feedback about their work environments. But collecting information and changing an organization are two different things.
Doucette said there are encouraging signs.
“We are seeing improvements in nurse engagement year over year since 2021,” he said.
He led nursing at a large academic health center through the pandemic, and he described how it hit a workforce whose engagement was already slipping.
“If we go back to about 2016, where nurse engagement had been coming down year over year, the pandemic took what was a shaky foundation, obliterated that to dust, and we’ve been rebuilding ever since.”
Still, he cautioned against assuming that improving averages mean every nurse is experiencing a better workplace. His test is the nurse who only works Saturday nights.
“When that nurse feels like they’re aligned with what the highest levels of the organization are doing in the organization, that’s when we’ve arrived at the work culture that we’re trying to build.”
But if that nurse feels disconnected, the work is far from finished.
“If you’re the Saturday night shift nurse and you’re not feeling it, then we’re not there yet.”
Doucette believes nurses should expect their feedback to lead to action.
“We have to demand that when we share the gift of our voice as clinical nurses, we expect people to do something about what we’re sharing.”
When asked who owns fixing unsafe work environments and declining nurse engagement, Doucette said the answer is everyone. But he was clear about where accountability begins.
“It always does start with leadership, and to me it always starts at the top.”
He believes hospital boards of directors must own quality, safety and engagement, particularly because they control the budget and the resources that shape the environment nurses work in.
But he also cautioned against a culture where clinical nurses wait for administration to solve every problem.
“The way you treat each other, how you hold each other accountable, all of those things play a really important part into the environment that you’re trying to build.”
He encouraged nurses to take part in engagement surveys and in shared governance, which many organizations now call professional governance. At the same time, leaders must be prepared to listen and act.
“If leadership isn’t taking that information and making change happen, then it’s just falling on deaf ears.”
Doucette’s own leadership philosophy reflects his belief that nursing administration exists to support the people providing direct patient care. In every orientation since his first CNO role in 2009, he has shown an upside-down organizational pyramid, with clinical nurses at the top and the CNO at the very bottom.
“Everybody in between is there to do one thing, and that is support the environment that our clinical nurses work in,” he explained. “CNO, least important person. Most important person is a clinical nurse.”
If more nurse executives thought that way, he said, “our work environments would improve at a much more rapid pace.”
He also offered advice for new nursing executives: resist the urge to arrive with immediate solutions.
“The first thing I always do when I’m new to an organization is I keep my mouth closed and my ears open for at least 90 days,” he said.
He tells new CNOs to avoid making decisions in their first 90 days unless something is urgent, and to keep a log of what they see instead, so they understand the organization before trying to change it.
Doucette’s commitment to workplace safety doesn’t come only from studying workforce data. He has experienced firsthand what happens when a healthcare workplace fails to protect its employees.
Near the end of the interview, Jana asked what he would say to nurses who have been assaulted, threatened or traumatized at work and are wondering whether it’s time to leave.
He chose to share a story he doesn’t often tell.
Years ago, while serving as a hospital’s director of emergency services, Doucette was making rounds when he noticed a triage nurse having trouble with a patient’s family member. To help defuse the situation, he asked the patient’s husband to step aside and share his concerns with him while the nurse cared for his wife.
Instead, the man turned around without warning, grabbed Doucette by the shoulders and pushed him into a counter.
“I ruptured my L5 and S1 and had surgery on my spine the next day and was out of work for three months,” he recalled.
“It was incredibly traumatizing to me,” he said. “It scared the crap out of me, and I honestly didn’t know if I could go back to work.”
The experience also changed the direction of his advocacy.
“It was in that moment that I realized I could start advocating for my staff.”
The physical effects remain.
“Every single day my back hurts for one reason or another, and I think about that moment,” he said. “I want to make sure that that never happens to somebody else. And I won’t stop advocating until I see that happen.”
For Doucette, workplace violence isn’t a statistic in a workforce report. It’s an experience that can change someone’s career, their health and their willingness to return to work.
He believes nurses have more collective influence than they sometimes recognize.
“There are over five million of us just in the United States alone,” he said, encouraging nurses to vote, talk to legislators and speak up about the conditions they face.
“We collectively have to find our voice in this space because what is happening today with violence against healthcare workers is not okay,” he said. “And we have to stand up for ourselves as step one.”
Listen to the full conversation with Jeff Doucette on the Nurse Converse Podcast, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
🤔 Has workplace violence ever made you think about leaving nursing? Tell us in the comments below.
If you have a nursing news story that deserves to be heard, we want to amplify it to our massive community of millions of nurses! Get your story in front of Nurse.org Editors now – click here to fill out our quick submission form today!






